How the heating-on-or-off comparison works
The rule is the gap, not the habit. A web page cannot feel your house — it has no thermometer, no thermostat and no meter on your boiler — so it works from the numbers you enter. A house loses heat in proportion to the gap between inside and outside, so the energy used is proportional to that gap times the hours it is held. Leaving the heat on all day holds the full gap for 24 hours; turning it down while you are away holds a smaller gap for those hours, then reheats. The reheat takes about as much energy as was saved while the house cooled — the saving comes from the hours the house sat at the smaller gap, not from magic. That is why the US Department of Energy puts a 7–10°F setback for 8 hours a day at up to 10% off a year's heating, and why the Energy Saving Trust says a boiler left on all the time uses more energy and costs more than one that comes on only when needed. This calculator runs that model — the degree-hour model — on your numbers: your fuel price, your system, your insulation, your comfort and setback temperatures, your hours away, the outdoor temperature and the season length — and prices both options side by side.
To use it:
- Pick your country and heating system. United States, United Kingdom, Germany, Canada or Australia; gas boiler, heat pump, electric heaters or oil boiler. The country sets your currency and the default fuel price — the US default is the EIA winter average, the UK default is the Ofgem price cap — and the system changes the maths, because a heat pump moves heat instead of making it.
- Say how well insulated your home is. Well insulated, average or draughty. Insulation decides how fast heat escapes — a draughty house loses heat fast, so the gap between the two options is bigger, and insulation would save more than either option.
- Enter the comfort and setback temperatures. Comfort is the temperature you want when you are home, usually 20°C (68°F); setback is the lower temperature while you are away, usually 15°C (59°F). The setback must be lower than comfort — and never below 13°C (55°F) while it is freezing outside, or the pipes can freeze.
- Say how many hours a day you are away, and the outdoor temperature. 8 hours is a workday; 16 or more is a weekend away. The outdoor temperature is the daytime average for your area in winter — 5°C (41°F) is a mild-winter example. The longer you are away, the more the setback pays.
- Check the fuel price, and the season length. The default price comes from your country and system — edit it to match your bill and the answer gets sharper. The season length, about 150 days for a typical winter, multiplies the daily saving into a season figure.
- Read the verdict and the side-by-side table. The calculator gives one verdict — turn it down, leave it on low, too close to call, or do not turn it that low — plus the cost of each option per day and per season, the saving, and the checks: the heat-pump recovery penalty, the damp watch, the freeze floor and the cross-check against the Department of Energy rule.
The scenarios at a glance
| Scenario | Cheaper option | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Workday away 8h, gas boiler, 20°C to 15°C | Turn it down | About 11% cheaper — the house sits at the smaller gap for 8 hours |
| Overnight, gas boiler, timer | Turn it down | The Department of Energy rule: 7–10°F for 8 hours saves up to 10% a year |
| Weekend away 48h, gas boiler | Turn it down to 13–15°C | A long absence gives the setback a long time to pay off |
| Heat pump, deep setback of 6°C or more | Leave it on low | The hard recovery eats the saving — often with backup heat |
| Heat pump, shallow setback of 1–2°C | Turn it down a little | Shallow enough that the pump recovers without backup heat |
| Freezing weather, setback below 13°C | Leave it on low | Pipes can freeze and burst below 13°C (55°F) — no saving is worth that |
| Well-insulated home, either option | Too close to call | Heat escapes slowly, so the difference between the two options is small |
| Away for 1–2 hours only | Leave it as is | Too short for a setback to pay — the house barely cools |
What makes this calculator different
The pages that rank for this search are guides — Kiplinger, Scoop HVAC, Raymond Plumbing and a handful of newer guides that all give the same static answer, "turn it down", and leave you to work out what it means for your house, your fuel price and your system. None of them prices the two options for your numbers, and none of them names the exceptions that change the answer: the heat pump that loses its saving to a hard recovery, the setback that drops below the freeze floor, the draughty house where the gap is twice as big. The closest interactive tools answer different questions — a space-heater cost calculator, a personal-heating savings calculator about blankets, a space-heater-versus-central-heat comparison. There is no free, standalone calculator that takes your country, system, fuel price, insulation, comfort and setback temperatures, hours away and outdoor temperature and prices "leave it on low all day" against "turn it down while away" side by side, per day and per season, with the freeze floor and the heat-pump penalty built in. This page is that answer: nine inputs, an instant verdict for your exact house, the blockers named, and the next steps.
When is this the right check?
When the heating bill arrives and you wonder whether leaving the heat on all day is the wasteful part of it — because the calculator puts a number on both options instead of a slogan. When you are setting a timer for the first time — because it tells you the setback temperature that actually saves money for your house. When you have a heat pump and the usual advice does not seem to work — because the calculator names the recovery penalty and shows you the shallow setback that does save. When you are going away for a weekend in freezing weather — because it refuses to recommend a setback below 13°C and says why. And when you are choosing between a smart thermostat and a timer — because the season figure tells you what the setback is worth over a whole winter.
Honest limitations
The money figures are estimates, not a bill
The money figures are the calculator's own estimates, built from the degree-hour model and the fuel price you enter. Your bill depends on your tariff, your insulation, your heating system and the weather — a heat pump, for example, saves less from big setbacks than a gas boiler does. Edit the fuel price to match your bill and the answer gets sharper.
The model is a simplification
The degree-hour model treats heat loss as proportional to the inside–outside gap, which is the physics every heating guide agrees on — but it does not model thermal mass, solar gain, wind, or a boiler that cycles on and off. A house with heavy masonry cools and reheats more slowly than the model says; a sunny room gains free heat the model ignores.
Insulation is three rough bands
Well insulated, average and draughty are rough bands, not a survey of your house. The heat-loss figures behind them — 110, 180 and 280 watts per degree — are typical values for a family home, not measurements. If your house is unusually large, small, old or new, the daily cost will be off even when the percentage saving is about right.
The freeze floor is a rule, not a guarantee
13°C (55°F) is the usual floor for an empty house when it is freezing, but pipes in an uninsulated wall or an unheated garage can freeze above it, and a house with the heating off entirely can drop below it fast in a cold snap. If the forecast says well below freezing, keep the heat higher and leave cupboard doors open under sinks on outside walls.
Heat-pump recovery is estimated
The 15% recovery penalty for deep heat-pump setbacks is the calculator's own estimate, not a measured figure for your pump. Real recovery cost depends on the pump, the outdoor temperature and whether backup heat kicks in — check your installer's advice for your model.
Rules from the DOE, Energy Saving Trust, EIA and Ofgem, dated November 2026
The rules here are the US Department of Energy, Energy Saving Trust, US EIA and Ofgem guidance as it reads in November 2026: the 7–10°F setback saving up to 10% a year, the boiler-on-all-the-time warning, the EIA winter-average prices and the Ofgem price cap. Tariffs change: recheck the fuel price when your tariff changes.