How to decide: take it, negotiate it, or walk away?
Most people ask this question the wrong way round: they start from the headline salary, and stop there. The honest framing is different. A job offer is three decisions at once — the money, the week, and the risk — and the decision has to pass all three tests. The pages that rank for this question are mostly guides: long articles that tell you to think carefully and then leave you to do the arithmetic yourself. None of them takes your pay, your hours, your commute, your benefits and your red flags, and gives you a verdict. This page does.
To use it:
- Enter the pay and the hours, in both jobs. The checker turns the headline rise into a real hourly rate: salary divided by the hours the role actually takes. A $10,000 rise that adds 10 hours a week is a pay cut per hour — and that is the number that matters, because hours are the part of your life you never get back.
- Price the commute in money, not minutes. Extra commute hours are hours you cannot spend anywhere else. The checker values them at your new hourly rate: a 60-minute commute, five days a week, is 460 hours a year — worth over $13,000 at a $30 hourly rate. A pay rise that does not survive the commute is not a pay rise.
- Compare the benefits — they are part of the pay. Holiday, health cover, pension or retirement match and bonuses can be worth 20–30% of the salary on top. A lower headline salary with better benefits can beat a higher one without them. Ask for the benefits in writing and compare them line by line.
- Run the work, growth and manager tests. Describe a typical day in the new role: if most of it is work you avoid now, a new employer will not make it feel different. Name two things you could point to after eighteen months that you cannot point to today. And meet the manager — people leave managers, not companies.
- Read the verdict and the score. The score adds up eight factors, and the table below the result shows every point, so you can see exactly which answer decided it — and what would have to change for the answer to change.
What makes this checker different
The pages that rank for this search are guides and partial tools. Lumen’s “Is This a Good Job Offer?” worksheet is the closest free rival: a careful ten-item checklist that explicitly says it is “not an accept/decline verdict” — it counts confirmed items and leaves the decision to you, with no salary maths and no commute pricing. Scamanot’s Job Offer Investigator checks only whether an offer is a scam. OfferLens is a service that researches an offer against salary benchmarks, with a CV upload and privacy terms that do not establish what happens to your data. AfricaX’s guide verifies whether an offer is genuine, for people weighing a move abroad. Nothing free combines the real hourly rate, the commute priced in money, the benefits, the growth, the manager and the red flags into a scored verdict with a negotiation list. This checker does: ten questions, a score out of 21 with every point shown, and four verdicts — take it, negotiate first, wait for the missing pieces, or walk away.
When is this the right check?
Whenever an offer lands and the first feeling is not excitement but unease: a higher salary with a much longer commute, a role that pays more but takes you away from the work you enjoy, an offer made by phone with nothing in writing, or a deadline to decide by tomorrow. It is also the right check when the offer looks generous — a big title and a big rise can hide a week you would dread, and the hourly maths is the fastest way to see through it. Run it before you answer, not after: a yes given in the moment is very hard to take back, and a polite “I need a few days to decide” is always reasonable.
Honest limitations
General information, not career or legal advice
This checker weighs your answers against the published job-offer guidance as it reads in November 2026. It does not know your contract, your employer’s policies, or your full finances, and it cannot tell you what is right for your career. For a large decision, speak to a qualified adviser first.
The score is a planning line, not a prediction
The score adds up eight factors with fixed weights — the real pay per hour, the commute cost, the benefits, the growth, the daily work, the manager, the red flags, and what saying no costs you. It is a way to make the trade-off visible, not a forecast of whether the job will work out.
Commute hours are self-reported, and traffic lies
The commute cost is only as honest as the minutes you enter. A 40-minute commute on paper is often an hour in traffic. Do the journey at rush hour before you accept — and enter the minutes it really takes, not the minutes the recruiter quoted.
Benefits are compared, not priced
The checker scores benefits as better, the same, or worse than your current job. It does not put a money value on holiday, health cover or a pension match — ask for the benefits in writing and price them yourself before you decide.
We do not fetch market rates
The checker uses only the numbers you enter. It does not look up what your role pays elsewhere, so it cannot tell you whether the offered pay is below market. Check levels.fyi, Glassdoor or live job postings for the market range before you negotiate.
Guidance dated November 2026
The rules here follow the published guidance as it reads in November 2026: the Federal Trade Commission’s job-scam figures, Lumen’s job-offer checklist, and the standard advice on written offers and negotiation. Guidance changes, so re-check if you read this later.