How to decide: should you accept a counteroffer?
Most people decide this question with their gut: flattered by the counteroffer, afraid of the new job, or angry at the old one. The honest way is duller — a short test, answered in writing, before you reply to anyone. It has four parts: does the counteroffer fix the reason you started looking, is it in writing with specifics, do you trust your employer to follow through, and would you have stayed happily on these terms if they had been offered before you resigned? If all four pass, staying is a real option. If any one fails, the new job is usually the better bet — and the numbers back that up: Hays' annual Salary Guide consistently finds around 46% of staff who accept a counteroffer leave anyway, and only 29% stay longer than 12 months. The pages that rank for this question are guides — Adecco, Hays, recruitment blogs — and the one interactive product, a $29 "Before the Counteroffer" kit, is paid. None of them takes your answers and returns a stay-or-go verdict for free. This page does.
To use it:
- Start with the reason you left. Pick the closest one — pay only, pay and other reasons, or mostly not pay. Everything else in the check is measured against it.
- Judge the fix, not the money. "Does the counteroffer fix that reason?" is a different question from "does it pay more?" If you left over a manager, the hours or a dead end, a bigger salary leaves the real reason untouched.
- Check whether it is in writing. A verbal promise stops the decision cold: this checker will not give you a stay verdict on a promise. Ask for the pay, title, hours and review dates in writing first.
- Compare the whole package. Pay, benefits, hours, commute and growth together — and check how firm the new offer is. A signed, unconditional offer and a verbal one are not the same thing.
- Read the verdict, then the blockers. The stay score is the summary; the blockers are the detail. A single blocker — it does not fix the reason, you do not trust them, it is only verbal — can outweigh a good score, and the checker says so plainly.
What makes this checker different
The tools that rank for this search answer a different question. Offer scorers such as RateMyOffer and Hayven's Offer Evaluator judge a new job offer against market pay — they do not weigh staying against leaving, and they do not ask whether the counteroffer fixes the reason you wanted to go. The guides — Adecco, Hays, and the woberry "Stay Test" framework this checker is built on — give you a list of questions to answer in your head. The only interactive counteroffer product that ranks is a paid kit. This page is the only free, no-sign-up checker that takes your answers — the reason, the fix, the writing, the trust, the package, your standing and your safety net — and returns a verdict with the reason named, plus the resignation and binding-offer rules for your country.
When is this the right check?
Whenever your current employer counters your resignation — whether the counteroffer is a raise, a promotion, a title change, more flexibility or a mix of them — and you have a new job offer to compare it with. It is also the right check before you answer a verbal counteroffer, and before you tell the new employer anything: the checker will stop you from deciding on a promise, and from resigning on a verbal offer. It is not the right check if you have no new job yet — then the question is whether to start looking, not whether to stay — and it is not a salary benchmark: it judges this counteroffer against this new job, not against the market.
Honest limitations
General information, not career or legal advice
This checker scores your answers against published guidance as it read in November 2026. It does not know your full circumstances — your contract, your notice period, your relationship with your manager — and it cannot advise you. For a decision that affects your income, speak to a qualified adviser in your own jurisdiction.
Rules differ by country and contract
Resignation and offer rules are national and contractual: UK rules on withdrawing a resignation and on binding offers are not the same as US at-will rules, and your own contract can add notice periods, non-competes and garden-leave terms this checker cannot see. Always check your contract before you decide.
The statistics are surveys, not guarantees
The Hays figures — around 46% of counter-offered staff leaving anyway, 29% staying longer than 12 months — and the Pew figures — 63% low pay, 63% no advancement, 57% feeling disrespected — come from surveys of other people. They describe what usually happens, not what will happen to you.
A score is not a verdict on your life
The stay score — accept at 7 or above, too close to call at 2 to 6, take the new job at 1 or below — is a planning line, not a fact about your future. A high score does not mean staying will work out, and a low score does not mean the new job is safe. The score tells you how the counteroffer measures up, not how either job will turn out.
Verbal promises and unwritten terms
This checker treats a verbal counteroffer as a blocker for a reason: promises that are not written down are hard to enforce and easy to forget. If your employer will not put the terms in writing, that refusal is itself information — treat it as part of the answer.
Rules dated November 2026
The rules here follow published guidance as it read in November 2026: the Hays Salary Guide findings, the Pew Research Center survey of US workers who quit in 2021, and UK government guidance on resignations and binding offers. Guidance, survey results and employment law change, so re-check the sources if you read this later.