How to decide: take it, negotiate it, or turn it down?
Most people ask this question the wrong way round: they start from the title and the pay rise, and stop there. The honest framing is different. A promotion is two decisions at once — the money, and the work — and the decision has to pass both tests. The pages that rank for this question are all guides: long articles that tell you to think carefully and then leave you to do the arithmetic yourself. None of them takes your pay, your hours, whether you want the daily work and what declining costs you, and gives you a verdict. This page does.
To use it:
- Enter the pay and the hours, in both roles. The checker turns the headline rise into a real hourly rate: salary divided by the hours the role actually takes. A 10% rise that adds 10 hours a week is a pay cut per hour — and that is the number that matters, because hours are the part of your life you never get back.
- Run the week test. Describe a typical Tuesday in the new role. If most of it is work you would avoid now — meetings, admin, managing people — the title will not make it feel different. Take a promotion when you want the daily work it brings, not just the title.
- Run the evidence test. Name two things you could point to after eighteen months in the new role that you cannot point to today. If you cannot name them, the promotion is a step sideways, not a step forward.
- Run the direction and cost tests. Is the role on the path you want in three to five years, or does it pull you away from the work you want to be known for? And what do you give up — the craft you enjoy, the evenings at home, or both?
- Read the verdict and the score. The score adds up eight factors, and the table below the result shows every point, so you can see exactly which answer decided it — and what would have to change for the answer to change.
What makes this checker different
The guides that rank for this search — Job-Genie’s work-life balance piece, OTOvios’s four tests, StaMatrix’s decision-matrix walkthrough, Eva Del Rio’s advice on turning a promotion down — all agree on the principles and none of them applies them to your numbers. The one dedicated tool in this space is a decision matrix for choosing between two jobs, which is a different question: it compares offers, it does not judge one promotion. Nothing prices the extra hours, runs the four tests and gives a verdict with a decline script. This checker does: nine questions, a score out of 21 with every point shown, the real hourly rate before and after, and four verdicts — take it, negotiate first, ask for a trial, or turn it down.
When is this the right check?
Whenever a promotion lands on your desk and the first feeling is not excitement but unease: a teacher offered head of department, an engineer offered a management track, a nurse offered a charge role, a parent offered a promotion that doubles the travel. It is also the right check when the offer is generous — a big title and a big rise can hide a week you would dread, and the hourly maths is the fastest way to see through it. Run it before you answer, not after: a yes given in the moment is very hard to take back, and a clear no given early, with an alternative named, is stronger than a yes you regret.
Honest limitations
General information, not career or legal advice
This checker weighs your answers against the published promotion guidance as it reads in November 2026. It does not know your contract, your employer’s promotion policy, or your full finances, and it cannot tell you what is right for your career. For a large decision, speak to a qualified adviser first.
The score is a planning line, not a prediction
The score adds up eight factors with fixed weights — the real pay per hour, the week, the direction, the cost, negotiability, timing, hesitation, and the cost of declining. It is a way to make the trade-off visible, not a forecast of whether the promotion will work out.
Hours are self-reported, and they creep
The hourly rate is only as honest as the hours you enter. Promotion hours creep: a role advertised at 45 hours often runs at 55 in practice. Enter the hours the role really takes — ask the person who held it before — not the hours in the job description.
Being good at this job tells you little about the next
A study of sales workers promoted into management, summarised by the National Bureau of Economic Research, found the best salespeople often made the worst managers. Skill in one role is a weak predictor of skill in the next — the week test matters more than your track record.
Declining has a real cost
A CV that stops moving while peers advance reads as stagnation to a recruiter, and the next opening may go to someone else. This checker prices that cost in the score — but it cannot price your manager’s reaction, which is why the “what happens if I say no” question is in the check.
Guidance dated November 2026
The rules here follow the published guidance as it reads in November 2026: OTOvios’s four tests, Job-Genie’s recruiter-fit argument, StaMatrix’s decision-matrix method, and the National Bureau of Economic Research summary of the sales-promotion study. Guidance changes, so re-check if you read this later.