How the rake-or-leave check works
Advice on this splits into two camps — “rake everything” and “leave the leaves” — and the guides that rank for this question all say the same thing in different words: the truth is a third option most people skip. What decides it is seven things: where the leaves are, how much of the ground they cover, whether they are dry or wet and matted, whether they are diseased, whether lasting snow is coming, whether you have a mulching mower, and whether the leaf drop is still going. The 20% cover rule is the test the university extension services use: if leaves cover about 10–20% of the lawn and the grass still shows through, leave them or mulch-mow them in. If the layer hides the grass, whole leaves shade out, smother and kill turf — shred them with the mower or move them off the lawn. And the place matters as much as the depth: in garden beds and under trees, healthy leaves protect roots and shelter overwintering insects, while on paths and in the street they must be cleared.
To use it:
- Say where the leaves are. On the lawn, the 20% cover rule decides it. In garden beds or under shrubs, healthy leaves stay — they protect roots and shelter overwintering insects and wildlife. On paths, steps, the driveway or the deck, sweep or blow them off: a wet layer is a slipping hazard. In the street, the gutter line or over a storm drain, get them out — they wash phosphorus into the water. Under trees and along shrub borders, leave them where they fell.
- Say how much of the ground they cover. Stand back and look: can you still see the grass through the leaves? About 20% cover or less can stay all winter. More than that, with the grass still visible, is the mulch-mowing range. A layer so thick you can barely see the ground must be shredded or raked off. A thick, wet mat — leaves pressed together with the grass hidden — must be raked off by at least half, before the first lasting snow.
- Say whether the leaves are dry or wet. Dry leaves shred; wet leaves must be raked off. A mulching mower chops a dry layer up to about 6 inches deep in one or two passes. Wet leaves clump under the deck instead of shredding, which can smother grass as effectively as leaving them alone — so if the leaves are wet, wait for a dry day or rake them into beds now.
- Say whether the leaves are diseased. Check for spots, scab or mildew. Diseased leaves must be raked out and destroyed, never composted and never left in beds: the fungus overwinters on fallen diseased leaves and re-infects the tree next spring. Do not mulch-mow them in either — shredding spreads the diseased fragments across the lawn instead of removing them.
- Say whether lasting snow is coming. Snow mould is one reason “just leave them” can go wrong in snowy regions: it thrives under snow on unfrozen ground, and raking up fallen leaves is on the fall prevention list. A thick layer pressed under lasting snow is what it thrives on, so clear heavy layers before the first lasting snow.
- Say whether you have a mulching mower. A mulching mower shreds a dry layer into the lawn in one or two passes, returning nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium to the soil — and three Michigan State University studies from 1990 found no negative effects of mulching leaf litter into the turf. Without one, the leaves must be raked into beds, where they work as winter mulch.
- Say whether the leaf drop is still going. Rake or mulch about every 7 to 10 days during peak leaf drop, rather than waiting for the tree to go bare. But below about 20% cover, raking too early is wasted effort, since the wind blows more leaves down the next day — wait until the drop slows, then check the cover again.
What makes this checker different
The pages that rank for this search are guides — a home-and-garden site laying out the 20% cover rule, a yard blog walking through the zones, a gardening site explaining the extension guidance. None of them scores your situation: none takes your place, your cover, your wetness, your leaf health, your snow, your mower and your timing — and none gives you a verdict — leave them, mulch-mow them, rake them into beds, or rake them off now — with the next steps for the verdict you got. There is no free, standalone checker that takes a yard's leaf cover and returns a rake-or-leave verdict with the 20% cover rule applied. This page is that answer: seven questions, and an instant verdict for your exact yard. It is a self-assessment, so it says plainly what it cannot know: it cannot walk your yard, see how deep the leaves are, or read a weather forecast, and where the leaves are diseased, on a path, or in the street it tells you to clear them instead of giving you a maybe.
When is this the right check?
When you are standing at the back door with the rake out, wondering whether the weekend's work is needed at all — because a light scattering is not a chore, it is free fertiliser. When the lawn has disappeared under a heavy layer after a windy week — because whole leaves left like that shade out, smother and kill turf. When the leaves are wet and matted and the mower is in the shed — because wet leaves defeat the mower, and the choice is rake or wait. When the first lasting snow is in the forecast — because a thick layer pressed under snow invites snow mould, which shows as dead, matted patches at the thaw. And when the leaves are in the beds and someone has told you to clear them — because in beds and under trees, healthy leaves protect roots and shelter overwintering insects, and the guidance is to leave behind as much as you can.
Honest limitations
A self-assessment, not lawn-care advice
This checker cannot walk your yard, see how deep the leaves are, or read a weather forecast. It scores the answers you give against what the leaf guides say — it cannot tell you what your lawn actually needs, and it is not lawn-care advice.
The 20% rule is a judgement, not a measurement
About 20% cover is the extension guidance's rule of thumb, not a number you can measure with a ruler. Stand back and look: if you can still see the grass through the leaves, the layer is thin enough. Leaf depth, tree species and wind all move the line.
Leaf species change the maths
Oak leaves and other thick, slow leaves break down far more slowly than maple or birch, and a layer of them mats more easily. The checker treats all leaves the same — if your leaves are mostly oak, lean towards shredding or raking sooner.
Wildlife and tidiness pull in opposite directions
Leaving leaves helps overwintering insects and wildlife, but shredding them with the mower can harm the insects using them. If wildlife matters to you, rake whole leaves into beds rather than shredding everything — the beds get the habitat, and the lawn gets the light.
Local rules decide disposal
Whether you may burn leaves, bag them for yard-waste collection, or compost them depends on your town's rules — and some places ban leaf burning outright. Check your local rules before you dispose of anything.
Facts from the leaf guides, dated November 2026
The facts here are the leaf guides that rank for this question — hearth-habit.com, thebackyardpost.com, ohsospotless.com and sowsprout.com, and the University of Illinois, Iowa State, Purdue, Michigan State, Colorado State and Wisconsin extension guidance they cite — as they read in November 2026. Guides change and seasons move: recheck the numbers if anything about your yard changes.