How to decide: hire a cleaner, or keep the hours?
Most people ask this question the wrong way round: they compare the cleaner's price with zero — “$150 a visit, or free if I do it myself” — and stop there. DIY only looks free if your time is free. The honest framing is different: a visit buys back the hours you would have spent cleaning, and those hours are worth whatever an hour of your time is worth. The pages that rank for this question never answer it for your household: they are guides and local-service pages that state the rule — a visit is worth it when it costs less than the value of the hours it returns — then leave you to do the maths yourself. None of them takes your hours, your hourly value, your quote and your household, and gives you a verdict. This page does.
To use it:
- Count your real cleaning hours. Not the tidy-up, the whole job: vacuuming, mopping, bathrooms, kitchen, dusting. The US Bureau of Labor Statistics time-use survey puts interior cleaning at about 1.5 hours on the days people do it, and a full clean of an average home at three to four hours of the owner's labour. If you clean twice a week, add both sessions.
- Price an hour of your time. Divide your annual salary by 2,000 working hours — the standard shortcut — or use what you would pay for a free hour of rest or family time. A $70,000 salary is $35 an hour. Try the check both ways: if the verdict flips, the answer is a trial, not a hire.
- Enter the quote, not a guess. The cleaner's price per visit and how often they would come are the numbers that decide the answer. Get two quotes, and ask each cleaner what a standard visit covers and whether the first visit — usually a deep clean — costs extra.
- Read the break-even hourly value. The visit cost divided by your monthly cleaning hours is the value your time would have to be worth for the maths alone to favour hiring. If your time is worth more than the break-even, hiring wins on maths alone. If it is worth less, hiring is a luxury purchase — which is fine, as long as you know it is one.
- Read the verdict and the score. The hire score adds up five factors, and the table below the result shows every point, so you can see exactly which answer decided it — and what would have to change for the answer to change.
What makes this checker different
The pages that rank for this search are guides and local-service pages. Hubbard's Maid Service gives the honest rule — a bi-weekly visit is worth it when it costs less than what your hours are worth — and a full guide on when to hire, but it is an article for one company's service area, and it never prices your household. Otesse's guide runs the same comparison in words, with the factors that move the answer. Care.com's budgeting guide covers how to fit a cleaner into a budget. Ezi.services does the opportunity-cost maths in prose for Canadian prices. Paige Simple, Shinenos and Love My Clean House all run the same numbers as worked examples for their own cities. Every one of them is a guide that tells you how to decide. Nothing free takes your hours, your hourly value, your quote, your frequency and your household — kids, pets, allergies — and answers the actual question with a verdict, a monthly and yearly difference, the hours freed and the break-even hourly value. This checker does: eight questions, a hire score out of 10 with every point shown, and three verdicts — hire it, try a trial, or keep doing it yourself.
When is this the right check?
Whenever the cleaning keeps slipping and the weekends keep disappearing: a new job, a new baby, a bigger home, or a chore that keeps not getting done. It is also the right check when a quote lands and the number looks big on its own — $150 a visit sounds like a lot until it is set against four hours a week of your time at $35 an hour. Run it before you book, not after: a recurring plan with no long-term contract is the one to ask for, and a three-visit trial is how you test the quality no checker can measure.
Honest limitations
General information, not financial or legal advice
This checker weighs your answers against the published cleaning and household guidance as it reads in November 2026. It does not know your contract, your tax position, or your full finances, and it cannot tell you what is right for your household. For a large decision, speak to a qualified adviser first.
Your hourly value is a judgement, not a fact
Salary divided by 2,000 hours is the standard shortcut, but rest and family time are worth whatever you say they are. The verdict moves with the number you enter, so try the check twice — once at your wage, once at what a free hour is worth to you.
A quote is an estimate, not a price
A first visit is often a deep clean at a higher price, and the recurring rate is usually lower. The checker uses the number you enter, so get two quotes and ask what a standard visit covers before you trust the verdict.
Quality is unknown until a trial
No checker can know a cleaner's quality until a trial visit. A cheap visit that skips the bathrooms is not the visit you priced here. Book three visits, then check the time back, the consistency, and whether the rooms that matter are actually clean.
Cash and time are different things
A visit is real money out of your account; the hours saved are only worth what you do with them. If the freed hours go to more work, price them at your wage. If they go to rest or family, the value is yours to set — and the verdict moves with it.
Guidance dated November 2026
The rules here follow the published cleaning and household guidance as it reads in November 2026: the opportunity-cost rule, the US Bureau of Labor Statistics time-use figures, and the typical visit prices quoted by the guides. Prices and practice differ by city and by cleaner, so re-check with a fresh quote if you read this later.