How to decide: hourly, fixed, or fixed with a cap?
Most freelancers ask this question the wrong way round: they start from what feels fair, and stop there. The honest framing is different. Hourly punishes you for being fast — finish a logo in six hours instead of twelve and you earn half. Fixed punishes you for being slow — a project that runs long is hours you work for free. The decision is really about who carries the risk when the work takes longer than expected, and the pages that rank for this question never answer it for your project: they are guides and generic rate calculators that tell you how to work out a minimum hourly rate, then leave you to do the pricing maths yourself. None of them takes your rate, your hours, your scope and your revision risk, and gives you a verdict. This page does.
To use it:
- Enter your hourly rate and the estimated hours. That gives the base fee: what the project pays if it is billed by the hour and the estimate is right. Every fixed price on this page is built on that number, never on a guess.
- Add the buffer the risk deserves. The standard advice is 15 to 25 percent for revisions, calls and surprises on a well-defined project. This calculator starts at a 10 percent floor and adds 5 points for each point of scope risk, revision risk and unfamiliarity — up to 50 percent — and rounds the fixed price up to the next 10. The buffer is shown, so you can see exactly what the fixed price is protecting you from.
- Read the break-even hours. The fixed price divided by your hourly rate is the point past which hourly would have paid more. A $1,060 fixed fee at $80 an hour breaks even at 13.25 hours — finish in 12 and the fixed fee pays better; take 16 and hourly would have paid $220 more. If the break-even sits almost on your estimate, the buffer is too thin.
- Read the verdict and the score. The score adds up six factors, and the table below the result shows every point, so you can see exactly which answer decided it — and what would have to change for the answer to change.
- Price the terms, not just the fee. A new or slow-paying client gets a deposit of 30 to 50 percent and milestones tied to deliverables, whatever the pricing model. The fee is not the risk — the terms are.
What makes this calculator different
The pages that rank for this search are guides and partial tools. BoredListed’s “How to Price Freelance Work” is the most thorough guide: it covers the rate formula, the benchmarks and the hourly-versus-project table, but it is an article — it never prices your project. LeverPoint’s Freelancer Rate Calculator and icalcapp’s Freelancer Rate Calculator both work out a minimum hourly rate from a salary goal, overhead and billable hours, and show a project rate as hourly times hours times a flat 1.2 buffer — no scope risk, no revision risk, no verdict. Floresta Creative’s pricing guide and EveryCentCalc’s rate guide are the same shape: good advice, a small minimum-rate calculator, and no per-project decision. Nothing free takes one specific project — its hours, its scope, its revisions, its client — and answers the actual question with a verdict, a recommended fixed price and the break-even hours. This calculator does: eight questions, a score out of 14 with every point shown, and three verdicts — fixed fee, fixed fee with a cap, or hourly.
When is this the right check?
Whenever a client asks for a fixed price and your first feeling is not confidence but a wobble: a brief that keeps growing, a client who wants “a few tweaks” with no number attached, work you have never done before, or a project whose hours you are guessing at. It is also the right check when the fixed fee looks generous — a big number can hide a thin buffer, and the break-even hours are the fastest way to see through it. Run it before you quote, not after: a fixed price given in the moment is very hard to take back, and a polite “let me work out the scope and come back with a number” is always reasonable.
Honest limitations
General information, not financial or legal advice
This calculator weighs your answers against the published freelance pricing guidance as it reads in November 2026. It does not know your contract, your tax position, or your full finances, and it cannot tell you what is right for your business. For a large decision, speak to a qualified adviser first.
The buffer is a rule of thumb, not a guarantee
The buffer starts at 10 percent and adds 5 points per point of scope, revision and unfamiliarity risk, capped at 50 percent. It is built from the standard 15 to 25 percent advice, not from your project’s history — a project with a genuinely unusual risk may need more, and only your own time tracking can tell you how much.
Hours estimates are self-reported, and optimism lies
The break-even is only as honest as the hours you enter. Most freelancers underestimate by a quarter or more, because the estimate forgets the calls, the fixes and the final polish. Track your hours task by task, and enter the hours the work really takes, not the hours you hope it takes.
Value is not priced here
The calculator prices your time, not the value of the work. A landing page that brings a client ten new customers a month is worth more than the hours it took to build — and no hourly maths can capture that. If the work is tied to a measurable business result, price the result, not the hours.
We do not fetch market rates
The calculator uses only the numbers you enter. It does not look up what your work pays elsewhere, so it cannot tell you whether your hourly rate is below market. Check live job postings and rate surveys for your field before you negotiate.
Guidance dated November 2026
The rules here follow the published freelance pricing guidance as it reads in November 2026: the 15 to 25 percent buffer, the scope and revision advice, and the standard deposit and milestone practice. Guidance changes, so re-check if you read this later.