How the air-fryer check works
The rule is your kitchen, not the adverts. Which? cooked the same four meals in an air fryer and in a built-in electric oven and measured the electricity, preheating included: the air fryer used 31% to 47% of what the oven did — roast chicken 0.54 kWh against 1.157 kWh, chips 0.287 against 0.863, a jacket potato 0.392 against 1.084, and a cake 0.223 against 0.71. Averaged, that is about 0.36 kWh a meal in the air fryer and about 0.95 kWh in the oven. This checker asks eight questions — how many people you cook for, what you cook, how often you would use it, how you cook now, your counter space, your budget, where you live and what matters most — and gives one verdict: buy one, skip it, worth it if you use it, or check your kitchen first.
To use it:
- Pick how many people you cook for. Just you, 2, 3–4, or 5 or more. The household size decides the size you need — too small and you cook in batches, too big and you heat a box you never fill. If you are not sure yet, the checker says so instead of guessing.
- Say what you cook most. Crispy foods, roast vegetables and chicken, frozen snacks, baking and large roasts, or mostly reheating leftovers. Air fryers are best at crispy foods and roasts; they do worst at baking and large roasts, which do not fit a basket.
- Say how often you would use it. Every day, 3–4 times a week, 1–2 times a week, or rarely. The habit decides it before the price does — an air fryer used once a month never pays for itself.
- Say how you cook now. A full-size oven, hob and microwave, a convection or toaster oven you already own, or mostly takeaway. A convection or toaster oven is already an air fryer in a different shape — buying one would duplicate it.
- Say what counter space you have. Plenty, a bit tight, or none — it would live in a cupboard. A family-size air fryer needs about 30 cm wide and 35 cm deep, and it only gets used if it stays out.
- Say what your budget is. Under $50, $50–$100, $100–$200, or over $200. The size you need sets the price, not the other way round — a family size typically costs about $120.
- Say where you live. United States, United Kingdom, Germany / EU, Canada or Australia. Electricity prices set the saving — the checker uses typical rates for your country.
- Say what matters most. Lowest total cost, healthier cooking with less oil, speed, or keeping the counter clear. Each one points at a different answer — speed and health point at buying, a clear counter points at skipping.
The sizes at a glance
| Your household | Size to buy | Typical price | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 person | 2–3 quart (small) | About $60 | One portion, no batches, cheapest to run |
| 2 people | 3–4 quart (medium-small) | About $80 | Two portions in one basket |
| 3–4 people | 5–6 quart (family) | About $120 | A family meal in one go |
| 5 or more | 7–8 quart or dual-zone | About $180 | Two batches otherwise — the saving halves |
| Mostly large roasts | Skip it | — | A whole chicken or a large roast does not fit a basket |
| Already own a convection oven | Skip it | — | You already own the same cooking method |
| Would rarely use it | Skip it | — | An air fryer used once a month never pays for itself |
| No counter space | Check first | — | A stored air fryer gets used once and forgotten |
What makes this checker different
The pages that rank for this search are guides — a pros-and-cons guide, another pros-and-cons guide, a forum thread where strangers argue about it, and a buying guide that lists where to shop. They all give you the same static answer — "it depends on your household and your cooking" — and leave you to work out what it means for your people, your meals and your counter. The cost guides that do exist compare watts and kilowatt-hours in the abstract and never ask how often you would actually use the machine. None of them asks how many people you cook for, what you cook, how you cook now, whether you have counter space, or what your budget is — and none of them tells you which size to buy or when the machine pays for itself. There is no free, standalone checker that takes a kitchen — household, cooking, frequency, current oven, space, budget, country and priority — and gives you one verdict with the reason, the running-cost maths and the next steps, without recommending a brand or a shop. This page is that answer: eight questions, an instant verdict for your exact kitchen, the blockers named, and the next steps. It is general buying guidance, so it says plainly what it cannot know: it cannot see your kitchen, your oven or your electricity tariff, and where the guidance is thinner — your tariff, the counter measurement — it tells you to check instead of inventing a number.
When is this the right check?
When the adverts have convinced you and the counter has not — because the question is not whether air fryers are good, but whether one is good for your kitchen. When you cook crispy foods or roast vegetables most nights — because that is where the machine earns its place. When you already own a convection or toaster oven — because the checker tells you plainly that you already own the same cooking method. When your household is five or more — because two batches eat the saving, and the checker shows you exactly how much. And when you are counting the cost — because the checker does the running-cost maths in your currency, with your country's rate, instead of leaving you with watts and kilowatt-hours.
Honest limitations
General guidance, not a product recommendation
This checker recommends no brand, no model and no shop. It cannot see your kitchen, your oven or your electricity tariff. It cannot tell you which model is quietest, which coating lasts longest, or whether the one on sale this week is any good — only reviews and the box can.
The rates and prices are estimates, not your bill
The electricity rates are the checker's own estimates of typical residential rates in November 2026, and the size prices are typical US street prices. Your tariff and your local prices will differ — the maths shows the shape of the saving, not your exact bill. Check your tariff before you trust the payback figure.
Not sure means the cautious answer
If you do not know how many people you cook for or how often you would use it, the checker refuses to guess — it tells you to count them. And if you are not sure about counter space or budget, it names that as still to confirm instead of assuming the kitchen is fine.
The saving assumes one batch
The running-cost maths assumes one basket per meal. A household of five or more usually needs two batches, which doubles the air fryer's electricity and halves the saving — the checker says so in the verdict, but if your portions are small, one batch may still do it.
Your kitchen is not the average kitchen
A special diet, a tiny flat, a shared kitchen, a bad back that hates lifting a heavy basket — any of them can outweigh the maths. If one side has a must-have the other cannot offer, that decides it, whatever the score says.
Rules from Which?, CNET and EnergySage, dated November 2026
The rules here are the Which? lab figures, the CNET wattage and hourly-cost figures, and the EnergySage typical-oven figure as they read in November 2026: the 31–47% range, the four meal-by-meal measurements, the 1,500-watt air fryer against the 2,500–5,000-watt oven, and the $0.52-an-hour oven against the $0.25-an-hour air fryer. Figures change: recheck if anything about your kitchen or the prices changes.