How the new-or-used rule works
There is no single answer to “should I buy a new or used car” — the answer is written by the total cost over the years you will own the car, not the sticker price. The shape is the same across every guide that ranks for this search: a used car is usually cheaper overall because it has already taken the steepest drop in value, but the saving shrinks when the loan rate is higher, the repairs climb with age, and the insurance follows the car. A new car loses roughly 20% of its value in the first year, then about 15% a year after that; a used car loses about 12% a year from its current price. The average new car cost $51,109 in November 2026 (Kelley Blue Book / Cox Automotive) against about $27,000 used — so the first-year drop on a typical new car is roughly $10,000 before you have driven it anywhere. The average new-car loan ran about 7% in the third quarter of 2026 against about 10.6% for used (Edmunds), with average monthly payments of $787 new against $582 used. And the sweet spot the guides agree on is a 2- or 3-year-old car from a dealer: in Carplus's study of 41,298 used cars, cars bought at 3 years old lost the least value over the next 3 years, at 23.0% of their price.
To use it:
- Pick your country. Warranties, consumer rights and currency differ: a new car usually carries a 3-year warranty in the US, 5 years in Australia, and a dealer sale carries a 12-month warranty in Germany and Consumer Rights Act cover in the UK.
- Enter the two prices. The new car's on-the-road price after any discount, and the used car's asking price — the price the seller actually wants, not a guide price. The gap between them is the saving you are weighing against everything below.
- Pick the used car's age and mileage. Age sets the repair bill and the depreciation: a 2-year-old car has taken the steepest drop already and is cheap to run, while a car over 8 years old is estimated at about $1,500 a year in repairs. Mileage and age together decide the risk: high miles on an old car means the big repairs are near.
- Say how long you will keep it. The longer you keep a new car, the more the first-year depreciation gets spread out — which is why buying new makes most sense when you keep the car for many years. The longer you keep a used car, the more its repairs add up.
- Say how you will pay. A used-car loan costs more — about 10.6% against about 7% for new — so a cheap used car on an expensive loan can cost more than a pricier new car on a cheap one. Paying cash removes the interest entirely, and the used car's advantage grows.
- Check the warranty and the history. A remaining manufacturer warranty or a certified pre-owned warranty cuts the repair bill sharply. A full service history from a dealer is the single best sign the car was looked after; an unknown history from a private seller is the biggest risk, and it is why the checker adds a pre-purchase inspection to the used car's cost.
- Pick what matters most. On a close call — the totals within 10% — the decision is about you, not the money: lowest cost, peace of mind, or the latest tech and safety. The checker follows your pick when the money is a tie.
What makes this checker different
The pages that rank for this search are guides — Carplus, Caribou, Gumtree, RACV and the first-car guides, each telling you the same rules in prose and leaving you to apply them to your own two cars. There is no free, standalone checker that takes your two prices, the used car's age and mileage, how long you will keep it, how you will pay, the warranty left and the service history, and gives you a verdict — buy new, buy used, buy nearly new, or walk away from this used car — with the total cost over your ownership broken down into depreciation, loan interest, insurance and repairs. This page is that answer: ten questions, an instant verdict for your exact two cars, the risks named, and the next steps. It is a self-assessment, so it says plainly what it cannot know: a car it cannot place by price is reported as “can't tell”, not guessed — and an old, high-mileage car with no history and no warranty is reported as a gamble to walk away from, not a bargain.
When is this the right check?
Before you sign anything — run the checker first, because the sticker price is not the answer and the total cost is what you actually pay. When the used car looks cheap, because the saving has to survive the higher loan rate and the repair bill before it is real. When you are choosing between a nearly new car and a brand new one, because the 1- to 3-year-old car is the sweet spot the guides agree on. And whenever a guide gives you a flat “used is always cheaper” without asking how old the car is, how you will pay, or how long you will keep it: this page runs the numbers for your cars, and says so where the answer depends on a check it has not seen yet.
Honest limitations
A self-assessment, not financial advice
This checker cannot inspect a car. It cannot tell whether the used car was serviced on time, whether the tyres are bald, or whether the seller is hiding a fault — so every buy-used verdict comes with a pre-purchase inspection, and if the car fails it, the verdict changes.
Every figure is a planning estimate
Depreciation, loan interest, insurance and repairs are estimated from published averages — Kelley Blue Book, Edmunds and Carplus — not quotes. A real insurance quote and a real inspection can move the numbers either way, and they decide what the estimates cannot.
Depreciation is not a straight line
The checker estimates a new car at 20% in year one and 15% a year after, and a used car at 12% a year. Real cars vary: some hold their value far better, some far worse, and a model with a known fault can drop faster than any average.
Some used cars are genuinely a gamble
Old, high-mileage, no history, no warranty, private sale — four risk factors at once. The saving on the price is likely to go straight into repairs, and a private sale gives you almost no comeback. That is not a limitation of the checker — it is the verdict.
The 20/4/10 rule still applies
Whatever the checker says, check the 20/4/10 rule before you sign: 20% down, a loan of 4 years at most, and total car costs at 10% or less of your gross monthly income. A verdict that fits the rule is a buy; one that breaks it is a car you cannot afford yet.
Rules from the guides, dated November 2026
The rules here are the car guides' shared rules as they read in November 2026 — Carplus, Caribou, Gumtree, RACV and the first-car guides, with prices and loan rates from Kelley Blue Book, Cox Automotive and Edmunds. Markets move: check the current averages before you buy.