How the lemon-law presumption works
Every US state and the District of Columbia has a lemon law for new vehicles, and most of them use the same idea: a presumption. If the same substantial defect needed a set number of repair attempts, or the vehicle spent a set number of days out of service for warranty repairs, inside the state’s coverage window, the law presumes a reasonable number of attempts have been made — and the manufacturer has to argue its way out of it. The numbers differ by state: usually 3 or 4 attempts, or 30 days out of service, inside 1 or 2 years. A serious safety defect usually needs fewer attempts — 1 or 2. This checker runs your state’s exact figures against the history you enter.
To use it:
- Pick your state. The presumption test is written state by state — the same repair history can qualify in one state and not in another. The state where you bought or registered the vehicle is the one that counts.
- Say how you got the vehicle. New, used or leased matters: only ten states have a dedicated used-car lemon law, so a used car is usually outside the state test and needs the federal fallback instead.
- Describe the defect. A substantial defect — one that impairs the vehicle’s use, value or safety — is the test. A serious safety defect (brakes, steering, stalling) needs fewer attempts in most states, so say so plainly if that is what it is.
- Count the repair attempts and the days out. Count only visits for the same defect, from the repair orders — each visit where the dealer had a real chance to fix it is one attempt. Add up every day the vehicle was at the dealer for warranty repairs, including days waiting for parts. Either number can meet the test.
- Say when the defect first appeared and whether it is still there. The presumption only applies if the defect appeared inside your state’s coverage window — the first repair order usually shows the date and mileage.
- Say whether you notified the manufacturer in writing. Several states require written notice before the presumption applies, and every state’s process starts with it. A certified letter counts; a phone call to the dealer may not.
What makes this checker different
The pages that rank for this search are guides, or law-firm quizzes that ask for your name, phone number and email before they tell you anything — and the quizzes that do exist cover one state each (California, Florida, Connecticut). There is no free, standalone tool that runs your repair history against your own state’s presumption test for all 50 states and the District of Columbia, without an account and without asking for contact details. This page is that answer: eight questions, an instant verdict for your state, the exact figures the state uses, the blockers named, and the next steps — including the federal Magnuson-Moss fallback when the state test does not apply. It is a self-assessment, so it says plainly what it cannot know: a web page cannot read your repair orders or your warranty, and a presumption is not a verdict.
When is this the right check?
When the dealer has tried to fix the same problem more than once and it keeps coming back: run the checker before the next visit, so you know whether one more failed attempt would meet your state’s test. When the vehicle has spent weeks at the dealer: the days-out-of-service route can meet the presumption even when the attempt count does not. Before you sign anything the dealer or manufacturer offers — a “goodwill” repair, an extended warranty, a trade-in — because signing can waive the claim. And whenever a law firm’s quiz asks for your phone number first: this page gives you the same screening without it.
Honest limitations
A presumption, not a verdict
Meeting the presumption test shifts the argument in your favour — it does not guarantee a refund or a replacement. The manufacturer can argue the defect is not substantial, that an attempt does not count, or that the defect was caused by misuse. Several states also require arbitration or a state programme first.
Same defect, same words
The attempt count is per defect, not per visit. If the dealer writes a different description on each repair order, the count can split across defects. Describe the same problem in the same words at every visit, and keep every repair order — they are the proof.
Safety defects need fewer attempts
In most states a defect that could cause death or serious injury needs only 1 or 2 repair attempts — 1 in New Jersey, Georgia, Virginia and West Virginia, 2 in California, Texas, Connecticut and Washington. Tell the dealer in writing that it is a safety defect; the checker applies the lower figure when you do.
Used cars are mostly outside it
Only ten states have a dedicated used-car lemon law. Everywhere else, a used car’s claim usually runs through the federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, state implied-warranty law, or dealer-fraud law. The checker says so plainly instead of pretending the state test applies.
Written notice matters
Several states require written notice to the manufacturer before the presumption locks in — Florida counts only 15 days out of service if you gave notice, Georgia’s presumption needs a final attempt requested by certified mail, and New York’s can turn on a certified-mail notice. Send it by certified mail and keep the receipt.
Rules from the states, dated November 2026
The figures here are the published presumption thresholds for all 50 states and the District of Columbia, cross-checked against 2026 sources (including the California Attorney General’s lemon-law page and the Connecticut Lemon Law Program). Where sources disagreed, the 2026 figure was used — Florida’s rights period is 24 months, Georgia’s is 24 months or 24,000 miles. Laws change: confirm the exact rule with your state attorney general before acting.