How to tell if a gift card deal is legit
A cheap gift card and a stolen one look identical on a listing. The checks below come from the US Federal Trade Commission’s gift-card guidance and from AARP and Bitdefender’s reporting on fake balance checkers — they take about two minutes, and they catch the scams that a price check alone misses.
- Start with the discount. On established resale sites, cards sell at about 2–15% below face value. A discount of 20–40% is unusual enough to deserve extra checks, and anything over 40% off a popular card is the main bait scammers use. A “free” card that asks you to complete deals is not a discount at all — it is a lead-generation funnel, and the card never arrives.
- Check who is actually selling it. The retailer itself is safest, then an established resale site with reviews and a written refund policy. An individual seller with no history, or a site you have never heard of, needs the other checks to pass cleanly. Search the seller’s name and the site together with “review”, “complaint” or “scam” — the check the FTC advises.
- Read the payment terms before anything else. A seller that wants cryptocurrency, a wire transfer, another gift card or a payment app with no buyer protection is, in the FTC’s words, probably a scam. A credit card lets you dispute a charge for a code that never arrives or does not work; the other methods give you no way back.
- Ask what happens if the code does not work. A legitimate resale site holds your money in escrow until you confirm the code works, and replaces or refunds a genuinely invalid code. If the site cannot explain that in writing — or hides the card’s region until after payment — walk away. A card issued for one country’s store will not redeem on another’s.
- Inspect the card or code itself. A physical card should be sealed with the PIN covered — if the scratch-off is already revealed, the balance may already be gone. Never enter a gift-card code on a “balance checker” site you found through a search or an ad: use the website or phone number printed on the back of the card. AARP warned in February 2025 that fake checkers can sit at the top of search results.
What this checker can and cannot do
It scores what you can see
Eight signals you can check yourself in two minutes — the discount against face value, where the offer came from, the seller, the payment method, buyer protection, the state of the card or code, the card’s region, and pressure tactics. Each one is weighted by how strongly it predicts a scam.
It cannot look up the seller or the card
It never sends anything anywhere, so it cannot check the site’s reputation, the domain’s age, or whether a card’s balance is real. A clean result means no warning signs in your answers — not a guarantee the deal is safe. If anything still feels off, trust that feeling and walk away.
It judges the deal, not the card
A genuine discount on a card you will never use is still wasted money, and a fake seller can charge a normal price. For the price side of a retail deal, use the Black Friday Deal Checker to test whether the discount itself is real.
General information, not legal advice
This tool scores the warning signs in the answers you enter. It is not financial, legal or tax advice, and it does not judge whether a trader has broken the law. If you have been scammed, report it — in the US to the FTC at reportfraud.ftc.gov and the FBI at ic3.gov; in the UK to Action Fraud; in Australia to Scamwatch.