How to tell if a Black Friday deal is real
A discount is only as honest as the price it is compared with. A crossed-out “was” price is a claim made by the store, not a record of what people actually paid — and some sellers raise the price a few weeks before the sale so a normal price looks like a discount. The one check that cuts through it is the price history: what did this exact item actually sell for recently?
- Find the lowest price in the last 30 days. On Amazon, tap the “Price history” link on the product page; on other stores, use Keepa, CamelCamelCamel or Google Shopping price tracking. Make sure it is the same model, colour and size — discounts are often shown on the one variant nobody wants.
- Compare today’s price with that low, not with the “was” price. If today’s price is below the 30-day low, the deal is real. If it is the same or higher, the badge is marketing. This checker does the arithmetic and grades the result: a genuine bargain is at least 10% below the 30-day low.
- Check the “was” price too. If the crossed-out price is far above anything the item sold for recently, the percentage was invented. The US Federal Trade Commission’s Guides Against Deceptive Pricing (16 CFR Part 233) say a former price must be one the item was genuinely offered at — and this checker flags a “was” price more than 25% above the recent low.
- Look further back before you buy. A price that beats the 30-day low can still be worse than the 90-day low. Enter the 90-day and 365-day lows and the checker tells you whether today is the cheapest in three months, or the lowest price of the year.
- Count coupons and cashback separately. A coupon can make a mediocre deal worth taking, but it does not make the store’s discount honest. Enter them and the checker shows the price you actually pay next to the verdict.
What the research says (November 2026)
The Groundwork Collaborative’s November 2026 study of 351 products from Amazon’s own Black Friday and Cyber Monday pages found that 29.1% were the same price or higher than their lowest price in the 30 days before the sale — 9.4% were more expensive — and 57.3% offered no saving against their lowest price in the previous 90 days. Amazon disputed the findings, saying 98% of the products in 2024 and 99% in 2025 met its rule that a deal badge means the price is at or below the lowest price of the prior 30 days. Both can be true: the badge guarantees the price is not above its recent low, not that it fell for the sale.
In the UK, the consumer group Which? tracked 175 home, tech and health products for a full year and found that not a single one was at its cheapest point of the year on Black Friday itself; on Amazon, 88% of the products had been the same price or cheaper at some other point in the year, and 63% had been cheaper outright.
Honest limitations
Price history can miss coupons
Some trackers record the listed price but not on-page coupon codes, so the “lowest price” you read may be higher than what shoppers actually paid. If a coupon was live, the real saving is smaller than the chart suggests.
Third-party sellers vary
On Amazon, the price history for “sold by Amazon” and for third-party sellers can differ. Check the history for the seller you would actually buy from — the cheapest listing is often a different seller with slower delivery.
The checker judges price, not the product
A genuine discount on a bad product is still a bad buy. Read reviews, check the exact model number, and make sure the deal is on the variant you want before the price decides anything.
General information, not financial advice
This tool does arithmetic on prices you enter. It is not financial, legal or tax advice, and it does not judge whether a trader has broken the law — the UK Competition and Markets Authority’s guidance on price transparency (CMA207, updated November 2025) is the reference for that question.