How the checker works out whether store brand is as good
There is no single answer to whether store brand is as good as name brand, because the answer is two numbers multiplied together: how much more the name brand costs, and how much the name brand actually buys you for that product. This checker does that multiplication in the open: it scores each product on the published evidence, compares the name-brand premium you enter against the threshold for that score, and prices the whole basket three ways — everything name brand, only the items the verdicts point to, and the saving between the two. Every assumption is labelled as the tool's own rating or example, and the evidence is named with its sources, so you can see exactly where each number comes from — and correct the one that matters most, your shelf price.
To use it:
- Say where you shop. Your country sets the currency. The example prices are in that currency — they are the tool's own examples, so replace them with the prices on your shelf.
- Say what matters most. Lowest price keeps the lines tight: the name brand has to earn its premium. Best taste lets the brand win at wider gaps for the items where flavour differs. Ingredients and safety raises the brand lines for personal care and anything you put on skin or in a child's mouth.
- Say what your monthly grocery budget is, if you like. The checker shows the smart list as a share of your budget. Leave it blank and everything else still works.
- Check the example basket, or load a different one. The family weekly shop loads first: 12 everyday items with example prices. Essentials is the six items most households buy every week; pantry and cleaning is eight cupboard and cleaning items. Or clear the list and build your own.
- Put in your own prices. For each product, the store-brand price, the name-brand price and how many you buy a month. The verdict follows the price, not the label — the same product can be a clear buy-store at a 60% gap and a buy-brand at 20%.
- Pick the right category for each product. The category sets the closeness rating: medicines, baking staples and milk score high; canned and frozen staples and cleaning goods score medium; condiments, snacks and personal care score low. The category list explains why each one scores as it does.
- Add products of your own. Anything you buy regularly — allergy tablets, rice, cereal, shampoo, bin bags — with its own prices and how often you buy it. Remove anything you do not buy.
- Read the result. The smart list names the items worth buying store brand and what they cost a year; the totals show what everything name brand would cost and what the smart list saves; the item-by-item table gives each product its verdict and its reason; and the tips show the next savings worth making.
The three numbers that matter most
Your price gap
The percentage gap between the store and name-brand prices is the single biggest lever. A 20% gap on ketchup is a different decision from a 110% gap on ibuprofen, even though both are store brands — and the gap changes by store, by season and by promotion. Check the shelf, not the label.
How close the store version is
Store brand buys the most where the rules make the two versions the same product — medicines, baking staples, milk — and the least where recipes differ and taste is personal. The evidence finds no meaningful quality difference either way for most of the shop; the difference that matters is the one you can taste, or the one on the ingredients list.
How often you buy it
A wide gap on something you buy every week adds up; a wide gap on something you buy twice a year barely matters. The checker prices the saving per month and per year, so the products you buy most often carry the weight they deserve in the answer.
What makes this checker different
The pages that rank for this search are guides: they explain the evidence and give you a rule of thumb, and then leave you to do the maths for your own basket. The calculators that exist work out lifetime savings from one price pair, or compare unit prices — none of them takes your prices for the products you actually buy and returns a verdict per item, with a yearly cost for the smart list against buying everything name brand. This page does that, entirely in your browser, with the model stated in the open: the closeness ratings, the premium thresholds and the evidence are all on the page, so you can check every number instead of trusting a black box.
When is this the right checker?
When you are standing in the supermarket wondering whether the store-brand ketchup is worth the saving — because the answer is a number in your currency, not a slogan. When you are setting a grocery budget and want to know what switching sensibly saves, rather than what switching everything saves. When someone in the house has a reason to care about ingredients — because the checker scores the products where those reasons actually apply, and skips the ones where they do not. And when the store-brand aisle feels like a compromise — because most of the time it is not one, and a per-item verdict is kinder than a blanket rule.
Honest limitations
An estimate, not a quote
This checker works out the verdict from the numbers you enter, entirely in your browser. It cannot know your shelf prices, your taste, or whether your household will actually use what you buy. If a product nobody uses costs 100% of its price, store brand or not.
The closeness ratings are the tool's own
The high, medium and low ratings are this tool's summary of the published evidence, not a laboratory judgement. The evidence itself is mostly about taste tests and farming and manufacturing practice, not about health outcomes — and taste is personal, which is why the checker has a try-both verdict instead of pretending the answer is always certain.
Taste is personal
Blind tests find 76% of store brands taste just as good as the name brand — which means 24% do not, and the ones that do not are concentrated in the taste-led categories. If your household can tell the difference and prefers the brand, the verdict that matters is theirs, not the checker's. Buy one of each once and let the family vote.
Prices change by store and season
A sale can make the name brand cheaper than the store version — and then the verdict flips to buy brand, because it costs no more. A promotion can make the store version cheaper still. Re-run the checker when the prices change — the verdict follows the price, not the label.
The example prices are examples
The baskets load with the tool's own example prices, in the currency of the country you pick. They are there so the checker shows a result straight away — they are not your prices, and they are not a survey of any store. Replace them with the prices on your shelf before trusting a verdict.
Evidence sources, dated November 2026
The evidence named on this page is: Consumer Reports' blind test of 70 store-brand products (January 2023); Consumer Reports on the usual 25% to 30% store-brand price gap; Circana data for the Private Label Manufacturers Association on private-label share; Numerator on household penetration; the FDA's rules for generic drugs and its standards of identity for foods; the FDA Interstate Milk Shippers List; and Dartmouth's Tuck School of Business research on private-label suppliers, as they read on 22 November 2026.