How the adhesive rule works
There is no single best glue — the answer is written by the two materials first, and by the job second. The shape is the same across every guide that ranks for this search: the pair picks the adhesive family, and the conditions refine it. Wood to wood takes PVA wood glue, clamped tight. Metal to metal takes two-part epoxy, abraded and degreased first. Two pieces of the same hard plastic weld with solvent cement. Polyethylene and polypropylene take almost nothing — a low-surface-energy acrylic or a superglue kit with a polyolefin primer, and even then the bond is modest. Silicone takes nothing at all except Sil-Poxy against silicone itself. And then the job changes the answer again: a load needs slow-cure epoxy plus fasteners, water needs a waterproof adhesive, heat needs a high-temperature rating, a bend needs a flexible glue, and a wide gap needs a gap-filler — superglue and contact cement both starve in a gap. Prep is the other half of the rule: adhesion is mostly surface preparation, and a clean, keyed surface is what makes even the best adhesive hold.
To use it:
- Work out both materials. Tap it: metal rings, plastic thuds. Look for a grain (wood), a glaze (ceramic) or a weave (fabric). On plastic, check the recycling number near the triangle: 2, 4 or 5 means polyethylene or polypropylene, which almost nothing sticks to; 1, 3, 6 or 7 are the glueable ones. The pair decides the adhesive, not either material alone.
- Say what the joint has to survive. A decorative craft joint, an everyday repair, a load-bearing joint, weather, water, heat or a joint that bends — each one points at a different adhesive, and a few of them rule the first choice out entirely. A safety-critical joint (stairs, shelving, a seat) should be designed so fasteners carry the load, not glue alone.
- Check the gap. Hold the pieces together dry. A tight, close-fitting joint takes any adhesive; a small gap takes a gel superglue or epoxy; a large or uneven gap needs a gap-filler — two-part epoxy or polyurethane — because thin glues run out of a gap before they set.
- Say how fast it must set. Only superglue sets in seconds, and only on a small, tight, non-porous joint. Everything stronger needs hours: plan for clamps or tape while it cures, and never trust a joint before its full cure time.
- Say whether the joint shows. A visible joint needs a clear-drying adhesive — clear epoxy, superglue or a UV adhesive. A hidden joint can take a messy gap-filler: polyurethane foams out and yellows, construction adhesive is thick and visible, contact cement leaves a brown line.
- Test on a scrap piece first. Glue a scrap of the same materials, let it cure fully, then try to pull it apart. If it fails on the scrap, it would have failed on the real joint — and the scrap costs nothing.
What makes this checker different
The pages that rank for this search are guides and charts — a glue matrix you have to read cell by cell, a brand guide that recommends its own products, a craft list that never asks what the joint has to survive. None of them takes your two materials, your load, your water, your heat, your flex, your gap and your deadline, and gives you one adhesive with the prep and the cure time. The closest thing to a matrix, David Veksler's Glue Chart, is a static table: it tells you the primary and the fallback per pair, but it leaves you to apply the load, weather and gap rules yourself, and it never says when glue is the wrong tool. This page is that answer: six questions, an instant verdict for your exact joint, the conditions that change it named, and the honest “no adhesive bonds this pair” where that is the truth. It is a self-assessment, so it says plainly what it cannot know: a material it cannot identify is reported as “can't tell”, not guessed — and where the bond is genuinely uncertain, on polyethylene and silicone, it says so instead of selling you a tube.
When is this the right check?
Before you buy glue for a repair — run the checker first, because the pair and the job decide the adhesive together, and the wrong tube is the most common reason a repair fails a week later. When one of the materials is plastic, because “plastic” covers five different answers and the recycling number is the difference between a weld and a waste of money. When the joint carries a load, gets wet, sits outdoors or near heat, because those are the conditions that rule the obvious glue out. And whenever a guide gives you a flat “use epoxy for everything” without asking what you are joining: this page applies the rule for your pair, and says so where the answer depends on something it has not asked.
Honest limitations
A self-assessment, not a workshop judgement
This checker cannot see your joint. It cannot feel how tight the fit is, weigh the load, or tell ABS from polypropylene by looking — so every verdict comes with a test on a scrap piece, and if the scrap bond fails, trust the scrap, not the checker.
Polyethylene and polypropylene stay uncertain
Even the right product gives a modest bond on PE/PP, and results vary with the exact plastic, the primer and the cure. The checker names the specialist product and the mechanical backup instead of pretending a tube of glue solves it.
Some pairs have no adhesive at all
Silicone against anything but silicone, and loaded polyolefin joints, have no reliable adhesive. That is not a limitation of the checker — it is the verdict, and the checker says it plainly rather than offering a glue that will not save the job.
Five-minute epoxy is not the strong epoxy
Fast-cure epoxy is convenient and weaker: the guides are explicit that it is not for long-term high-load or wet bonds. The checker recommends slow-cure epoxy for anything that carries a load, and says so where speed tempts you the other way.
Brands change; chemistry does not
Product names are examples, not endorsements: the checker recommends adhesive types (PVA, epoxy, polyurethane, contact cement), because the type is what matters and the brands on the shelf change. Check the product label before you buy.
Rules from the guides, dated November 2026
The rules here are the adhesive guides' shared rules as they read in November 2026 — David Veksler's Glue Chart, Loctite, EngineerFix, Hunker, Rothko and Frost and FaveCrafts. Products change: check the adhesive tin's own instructions before you start.