How the who-pays check works
The rule is simple: the landlord pays for wear and tear, age and faults in the property — the structure, the heating, the hot water, the plumbing, the electrics and anything that makes the home unliveable. You pay for damage you cause and for minor upkeep. The cause decides the borderline cases, and a lease clause cannot move a legal duty from the landlord onto you. This checker takes six answers — where the home is, what broke, what caused it, how urgent it is, what the lease says, and whether you have reported it in writing — and gives you a verdict: your landlord pays, you pay, usually your landlord, usually you, or check your lease first. When the cause is not confirmed, it softens the verdict to usually instead of guessing, because a blocked drain from misuse is yours and the same drain blocked by a broken pipe is your landlord’s.
To use it:
- Say where the home is. The rule is the same in outline everywhere, but the law behind it is the US implied warranty of habitability or the UK Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, section 11 — pick your country so the verdict names the right one.
- Pick what broke. The rule depends on the item, not just on the fact that something broke. Heating, hot water, plumbing, electrics and the structure are your landlord’s; your own appliances and small upkeep are yours; a landlord-provided appliance depends on the agreement.
- Say what caused it. This is the answer that decides the borderline cases. Wear and tear is your landlord’s bill; damage by you, your household, a guest or a pet is yours. If you genuinely do not know, say so — the checker will say usually instead of guessing.
- Say how urgent it is. No heat, no hot water, a leak or no electricity makes the repair urgent — and urgency changes what your landlord has to do, and how fast.
- Say what the lease says. The lease can add duties to your landlord, and for a landlord-provided appliance it is the whole answer. It cannot take the landlord’s legal duties away: in the UK, section 12 of the 1985 Act makes a clause that excludes or limits the section 11 duties void.
- Say whether you have reported it in writing. Email or a message you can keep, with photos and the date. In the UK your landlord is generally not liable until put on notice, and everywhere else a written record is what turns a phone call into evidence.
What makes this checker different
The pages that rank for this search are guides — a rental site explaining who is responsible, a property-management blog laying out the general rule, a lease-review service explaining repair clauses. None of them answers your repair: none takes what broke, what caused it and where the home is, and gives you a verdict — your landlord pays, you pay, or check your lease first — with the rule behind it in one line and the next steps for the verdict you got. There is no free, standalone checker that does all of that. This page is that answer: six answers, and an instant verdict for your exact repair. It is general information, so it says plainly what it cannot know: it cannot know what your lease actually says, what your state or council requires, or what caused the fault, and it softens the verdict when the cause is not confirmed instead of giving you a maybe.
When is this the right check?
When something in your rented home has just broken and the landlord says it is your bill — or you are not sure whose it is and you do not want to pay for a repair that is legally theirs. When the boiler has died in winter and you need to know, today, whether the landlord has to act and how fast. When the lease says you pay for something and you want to know whether that clause can actually stand. And when a blocked drain, a damp patch or a broken appliance sits in the grey area between wear and tear and damage — because that is exactly where a checker that asks about the cause earns its keep.
Honest limitations
General information, not legal advice
This checker cannot know what your lease actually says, what your state or council requires, or what caused the fault. It applies the general rule and names the law behind it — it cannot tell you what your lease means, and it is not legal advice.
The cause is the whole case
Every verdict here rests on the cause, and the cause is often disputed. A plumber’s or electrician’s report is what settles a blocked drain or a leak — until you have one, the verdict is a usually, and the checker says so.
The law varies by place
The outline holds in most places, but the exact duties, deadlines and remedies vary by country, state and city. Repair-and-deduct rights, notice periods and the authorities you can call all depend on where you live — check your local tenancy law before you rely on any verdict.
Appliances are the exception
In the UK, section 11 does not cover appliances that use the supply, such as a fridge, cooker or washing machine — only the tenancy agreement can make a landlord-provided appliance the landlord’s job. That is why this checker says check your lease first for appliances instead of guessing.
Urgency does not change who pays
An urgent repair is still paid for by whoever the rule says pays for it — urgency changes how fast the landlord has to act, not whose bill it is. If the repair is yours and it is urgent, fix it promptly and safely rather than waiting for the argument.
Facts from the guides, dated November 2026
The facts here are the tenancy guides that rank for this question and the law they cite — the US implied warranty of habitability, the UK Landlord and Tenant Act 1985, sections 11 and 12, and Shelter England — as they read in November 2026. Laws change and guides are re-run: recheck the numbers if anything about your tenancy changes.