How the repair-or-replace rule works
Every broken washer is triaged the same way, and the part comes first: a pump and a transmission are both "a broken washer", but they are opposite answers. The age comes second, because the same repair bill buys very different amounts of remaining life on a 2-year-old washer and an 11-year-old one. Then the quote is divided by the price of a comparable new washer, and the result is compared with an age-adjusted limit — 50% under 3 years, 40% at 4–6 years, 30% at 7–9 years, 20% at 10–12 years, and replace regardless at 13 years or more unless the fix is trivial. The rules in this checker come from published repair guidance as it reads in November 2026, and the shape is the same almost everywhere: cheap part on a young washer means repair, major part on an old washer means replace, and a second breakdown in two years tips the answer toward replacement.
To use it:
- Pick the part that failed. The rule is written part by part — the same $300 means something different on a drain pump than on a control board, and a part the guidance gives as a range is reported with the range named, not collapsed to a single number.
- Say how old the washer is. The age sets the limit: under 3 years the repair can cost half a new washer and still be worth it; at 10–12 years the limit is 20%. The manufacture date is usually encoded on a label inside the door, on the back panel, or under the lid.
- Pick your currency. Part cost ranges are converted at approximate rates, and the verdict uses the ratio of repair to replacement — so the currency changes the numbers, not the answer.
- Enter the repair quote. Parts and labour, as the technician quoted it. Leave it blank and the checker estimates from the middle of the part's typical cost range — and says so, instead of pretending the estimate is a quote.
- Enter the price of a comparable new washer. Same size and load capacity, installed, with the old one taken away. Leave it blank for the typical price in your currency.
- Say whether it has broken down before. Two or more significant repairs in two years tip the answer one step toward replacement — a washer that keeps breaking is telling you something.
- Say whether there are any safety red flags. A burning smell, sparking, a tripping breaker or water on the floor overrides the maths entirely: stop using the washer until it is checked.
- Say how many loads a week you run. A new ENERGY STAR certified washer uses about 20% less energy and about 30% less water than a standard one — the saving scales with how much you wash, and it counts when the answer is close.
Every part, and what it usually costs
The table below is rendered from the same data the verdicts use, so the table and the checker can never disagree. Costs are typical 2026 US ranges, parts and labour included — brand, model, location, labour rates and the exact failure can move the real bill well outside them.
What makes this checker different
The pages that rank for this search are guides — a repair company's article, a retailer's cost guide, a manufacturer's blog — and the interactive tools that do rank are generic appliance calculators: they cover every appliance with the same flat 50% rule, in dollars only, with no part guidance and no energy saving. The one washer-specific calculator that ranks is a repair-cost estimator buried inside an article, not a repair-or-replace decision. There is no free, standalone checker that takes your washer's failed part, its age, your quote and the price of a comparable new washer, and gives you a repair-or-replace verdict with the age-adjusted rule, the part's own cost range, the breakdown history and the energy saving a new washer would bring — in five currencies. This page is that answer: eight questions, an instant verdict for your part, the blockers named, the cost-per-year comparison, and the next steps. It is a self-assessment, so it says plainly what it cannot know: a web page cannot look inside your washer or test its parts, and a repair figure the guidance gives as a range is reported with the range named, not guessed.
When is this the right check?
When the technician has just quoted you a repair and you are deciding whether to authorise it — run the checker first, because the part, the age and the quote decide the answer together, and authorising a $600 repair on a 12-year-old washer can cost more than the new machine would have. When the washer has broken down for the second time in two years — the checker counts the pattern. When the quote is close to half the price of a new washer — the checker tells you whether the age makes it a repair or a replacement. And whenever a guide gives you a rule without a verdict: the rule is only half the question, and the verdict is the half that decides what you do next.
Honest limitations
A self-assessment, not repair advice
This checker cannot look inside your washer, test its parts, or hear its bearings. Get a technician to look at the washer before you rely on it, especially if it smells, sparks, trips the breaker or leaks.
Where sources disagree, the stricter answer wins
Some parts are given different cost ranges by different sources — a control board is $250–600 in one guide and higher in another. This checker uses the published ranges and names them as ranges, instead of picking one silently.
The part beats the price
A cheap quote for a major part on an old washer is still a bad repair — the part is what decides whether the fix lasts. If the diagnosis names a different part than you entered, re-run the checker with the right one.
Currency conversions are approximate
Part cost ranges are US figures converted at approximate rates (GBP 0.79, EUR 0.92, CAD 1.36, AUD 1.52 per USD). The verdict uses the ratio of repair to replacement, so a rough conversion cannot flip it — but the money figures are estimates, never quotes.
The energy saving is an estimate
The saving from a new washer is roughly $80–130 a year for a typical household, scaled by your loads a week. Your water and electricity rates, and how hot you wash, move the real figure — treat it as a planning number.
Rules from published guidance, dated November 2026
The rules here are the published repair-vs-replace figures, checked against repair-company guides, retailer cost guides and ENERGY STAR guidance in November 2026. Guidance changes: confirm the exact quote with a technician, and the exact price with a retailer, before you pay for either.