How the regrout-or-retile rule works
There is no single answer to “should I regrout or retile” — the answer is written by the grout, the tiles, what is behind them, and where the grout failed, in that order. The shape is the same across every guide that ranks for this search: grout is porous, so it soaks up moisture, soap scum and mould over time, and once it starts to crack, crumble or go missing, no amount of scrubbing brings it back — the only fix is to cut it out and regrout. But regrouting only works when the tiles themselves are sound: a tile that has lost its bond keeps moving, and new grout laid over it cracks in the same places, often faster. What ruins a job is new grout skimmed over old grout, or grout laid in a corner that needed caulk: it looks fixed for a season, then fails in exactly the same place.
To use it:
- Run the tap test. Tap each tile gently with a coin or a small mallet, at the corners and the centre. A solid, even sound means the tile is bonded; a hollow thud means it has lost its bond. Press the tile too — a loose tile moves under your hand. This one test decides whether the job is a regrout or a retile, so do it before anything else.
- Look at the grout. Stained but intact grout is a cleaning job: deep-clean it, let it dry, and seal it. Cracked, crumbling or missing grout is a regrouting job. Mould that comes back within 2 to 4 weeks of a thorough clean has colonised the grout itself — it has to come out, not just be cleaned again.
- Check what is behind the tiles. Press the wall or floor around the tiles. If it feels soft, spongy or crumbly, water has reached the backing — the section has to be opened up, the backing repaired, and then retiled. Water stains or leaks mean the same thing with a cause attached: fix the water source first, or regrouting only traps the water behind the tiles.
- Look at where it failed. Flat joints between tiles are what regrouting is for. Inside corners, where the wall meets the tub or shower pan, and around fixtures are flex points — the joint moves as the building moves, and grout cracks there because it cannot flex. Those joints take flexible silicone caulk, not grout.
- Check the joint depth. Sanded grout needs at least 3 mm of depth to bond and cure. If the old grout fills the joint nearly flush with the tile face, there is no room for a new layer: cut the old grout back with a grout saw or an oscillating tool first. A thin skim over old grout cracks and falls out within months.
- Cut the old grout out — never grout over it. The guides agree on this, and they agree on why: new grout will not bond to old grout, so any cracking, crumbling or discolouration in the old layer comes straight through the new one. Remove the failed grout to at least 3 mm deep, clean the joints, and lay fresh grout of the same type — sanded over sanded, unsanded over unsanded.
- Let it cure, then seal it. Most grouts need 24 to 72 hours to cure fully — keep the shower dry in that time, or the grout washes out of the joints before it has set. Once it has cured, seal it: a sealer fills the pores and keeps the next stain on the surface instead of in the grout. In a pool, use a grout rated for continuous submersion — an ANSI A118.3 epoxy or an ANSI A118.7 high-performance cement grout — never ordinary sanded wall grout.
What makes this checker different
The pages that rank for this search are guides — Checkatrade, ATG Ltd, Groutastic, Cesar & Cesar Builds and WeFixUglyPools explain the 3 mm rule, the tap test and the regrout-versus-retile line in prose. None of them answers the decision: should your tiles be cleaned, regrouted, caulked or retiled? This page is the answer for your tiles: eight questions, an instant verdict for your exact surface — clean and seal it, regrout it, caulk it, or retile — with the blocker named, the joint-depth test, and the next steps. It is a self-assessment, so it says plainly what it cannot know: a surface whose tiles have not been tapped is reported as “can’t tell”, not guessed — and a loose tile or a soft wall is never given the benefit of the doubt, because the guides all agree those must not be regrouted over.
When is this the right check?
When the shower grout has gone black and you are choosing between a deep clean and a regrout. When the grout is cracked and you want to know whether cutting it out is enough, or whether the tiles underneath have already failed. When the corners keep cracking no matter how often you grout them — they need caulk, and this page says so. When a tiler has quoted for a full retile and you want a second opinion on whether the tiles are actually sound. And whenever a guide gives you a flat “just grout over it” without asking whether the tiles are loose or the joints have depth: this page applies the rule for your tiles, and says so where the answer depends on a test it has not seen yet.
Honest limitations
A self-assessment, not a tiler’s judgement
This checker cannot tap your tiles. It cannot feel whether the wall behind them is soft, see whether a tile is hollow underneath, or check the waterproofing — so every regrout verdict comes with the tap test, and if the new grout cracks again within weeks, a tiler should look at the surface before you carry on.
Regrouting is not a waterproofing repair
Fresh grout keeps surface water out of the joints, but it does not replace a failed waterproofing membrane behind the tiles. If the wall is soft or the shower leaks, the membrane has failed and the section has to be opened up — regrouting only hides the evidence.
Mould is a ventilation problem too
Removing mouldy grout fixes the grout, not the room. A bathroom that never dries out grows mould on any grout, old or new — run the extractor fan during and after showers until the room is dry, or the mould comes back on the fresh grout as well.
Old floors can hide asbestos
Floor tiles in 9-, 12- or 18-inch squares in a home built before 1980 may contain asbestos, and so can thick black adhesive underneath. Do not sand, drill, saw or tear out a floor like that until it has been tested — call your local building authority first.
Matching old grout is hard
New grout rarely matches old grout in colour, even from the same bag: age, water and cleaning change the shade. If the grout has failed across the whole surface, regrout the whole surface in one pass rather than patching a few joints — patches show.
Rules from the guides, dated November 2026
The rules here are the guides’ shared rules as they read in November 2026 — Checkatrade, ATG Ltd, Groutastic, Cesar & Cesar Builds and WeFixUglyPools. Products change: check your own grout’s label and run the tap test before you start.