How to replace a meeting with async
Most meetings are not discussions — they are updates read aloud. A thirty-minute status meeting with six people costs three hours of collective time, while the same update takes fifteen minutes to write and three minutes each to read. This planner scores your meeting on six factors, tells you honestly whether it earns a live slot, and drafts the async replacement for you.
- Describe the meeting. Its purpose, how many people attend, how long it runs, how often it repeats, whether a decision is needed, and how urgent the outcome is — plus the agenda, one item per line.
- Read the verdict. 75 and over means replace it with async; 50–74 means go hybrid — async first, with a 15-minute live slot only for disagreements; 25–49 means keep it live but cap it at 25 minutes; under 25 means keep it live.
- Check the score breakdown. Each factor shows its points and the reason behind them, so you can see exactly what is keeping the meeting live — and what would change the verdict.
- Send the draft. Edit the bracketed parts, copy it into your team channel or email, and set a reply deadline. Tell people the meeting is moving async — do not just cancel it.
- Review after four weeks. If nothing got missed, the slot stays cancelled. If a real disagreement surfaced, that is what the 15-minute live follow-up is for.
How the async score is worked out
Six factors, out of 100. The weights are the point: what a meeting is for matters more than how long it runs.
| Factor | Max points | What scores highest |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | 30 | Status updates and reviews — one-way information. Social time scores lowest: it is the meeting. |
| Decision needed | 20 | No decision at all. Real-time debate scores 2 — it is the strongest case for meeting live. |
| Urgency | 15 | No rush. A decision needed within 24 hours scores 2. |
| Time zones | 10 | Attendees spread across time zones — a live slot always excludes someone. |
| Sensitivity | 10 | Not a sensitive topic. Sensitive or personal topics score 0. |
| Agenda | 15 | A long, clear agenda — that is a document, not a meeting. No agenda scores 6. |
Honest limitations
It is a heuristic, not a guarantee
The score comes from the six answers you give. It cannot read your real calendar, your team's habits, or the politics of a meeting. A high score is a strong hint, not permission to cancel without telling anyone.
It cannot read your calendar
This tool has no calendar access and never asks for it. It does not know who is actually free, what else is on the agenda, or whether the meeting is really about something else entirely.
Time saved is an estimate
The estimate assumes about 20 minutes to write the update and 4 minutes per person to read it, and counts daily meetings as 250 weekdays a year. Real reading and writing times vary — treat the hours as a direction, not a measurement.
The reply deadline is yours to set
The draft suggests a reply deadline, but only you know what your team will respect. Set it to a date people will actually meet — and say what silence means, or the deadline means nothing.
Some meetings earn their slot
Real-time debate, sensitive conversations and fast decisions need a live room. When the planner says keep it live, the fix is a shorter meeting with an agenda sent in advance — not another async attempt.