How to check whether AI answers agree with each other
Ask the same question to two AI models and you will often get two confident answers that disagree on the numbers. One says the tower is 300 metres tall, the other says 324. One says 6.3 million visitors, the other says 5.1 million. Both sound sure of themselves — and reading both answers end to end to spot the differences is slow, boring work that people skip. This checker does the boring part for you: it pulls the checkable details out of each answer and lines them up side by side.
To use it:
- Paste the question (optional) — it is only used as a heading in the downloaded report, so you remember what you were checking.
- Paste each answer into its own panel and pick which model it came
from. Two panels are shown by default; add up to four. You can also load an answer
from a
.txtfile instead of pasting. - Press Compare answers. The checker splits each answer into sentences, keeps the ones that carry a checkable detail — a number, a date, a name, a quotation, a superlative or a cause-and-effect link — and scores each claim by risk, so the claims most worth verifying sort first.
- Work through the contradictions first. Each one shows the conflicting values side by side with the exact sentences they came from, so you can see what to verify. Then check the details only one answer mentions, and treat the agreed details as "no contradiction found here" — not as proof.
What makes this checker different
The pages that top the results for this search are consensus platforms that query the models themselves — Satcove, Council AI, Talkory and ConvergePanel all send your question to several models on their servers, score the agreement and show you a consensus, usually with a free tier of a few queries a week. None of them lets you paste answers you already have and flag claim-level contradictions between them. The one free paste-and-compare tool we found, the AI Response Comparator on aitoolcritic.com, scores answers against requirements and rubrics — it does not extract claims or flag where two answers contradict each other on the same fact. This page is the free, fully client-side, no-account tool that does exactly that: paste 2–4 answers you already have, get the contradictions, the details only one answer mentions, and the details they agree on — with a downloadable Markdown report and a claims CSV, and a live network-request counter so you can verify the privacy claim yourself.
When is this the right check?
Whenever you are about to rely on a figure, a date or a quotation that came from an AI answer: citing a number in an article, quoting a statistic in a report, checking a draft that leans on one model's answer, or comparing what different models say before you pick one to trust. It is also a fast way to see how much two models actually agree — the agreement percentage is the share of checkable details they state the same way, which is a far more useful number than how confident either answer sounds.
Honest limitations
Agreement is not truth
Several models can share the same wrong fact — they train on overlapping sources and repeat the same popular errors. Agreement only means no contradiction was found here. Verify anything important against a primary source.
It never decides who is right
The checker flags where answers disagree; it does not pick a winner and it cannot tell you which value is correct. A contradiction is the starting point for verification, not the answer.
It does not query any AI model
You paste the answers yourself — the tool never contacts ChatGPT, Claude or any other model, and it cannot fetch fresh answers for you. If you want a live multi-model comparison, a consensus platform is the right tool for that job.
It cannot convert units
The same quantity in different units — 100 metres vs 328 feet — is never flagged as a contradiction or an agreement, because the tool cannot convert units. Both details appear under "only in one answer" instead.
It only sees checkable details
Opinions, advice and reasoning steps with no numbers, dates, names, quotations, superlatives or cause-and-effect links produce no claims and are not compared. Quotations must be in double quotes to be detected, and names need two or more capitalized words.
Matching is keyword-based
Two details are treated as being about the same thing when they share a content keyword and the same unit. Two sentences about different things that happen to share a keyword can be compared — read the flagged sentences before acting on a contradiction.